GTA 6 Metacritic User Score Falls Despite Critic 99
Short answer: GTA 6 holds a 99 critic score on Metacritic, but its user score fell to about 4.9 within a day of launch, based on roughly 6,800 ratings. Metacritic had already removed fake user reviews posted before release. Many low scores look like one-line votes, so the score says little about the game itself.
By Mia Carter · Sources checked by GTA6Geek Editorial · Published · Last updated · 6 min read
Image: Rockstar Games← Back to all GTA 6 missions and guides
On this page
Critics and players disagree
Metacritic lists GTA 6 on PlayStation 5 at 99 out of 100 from 152 critic reviews, according to VGTimes. That ties The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time for the highest score on the site. The user score tells a very different story. VGTimes reported on 21 November 2026 that it had dropped to 4.9 out of 10 after about 6,800 ratings.
Both numbers can move. Metacritic user scores swing a lot in the first days, because a small number of votes counts for a lot and angry or enthusiastic players tend to vote first. We cover the critic side in our Metacritic 99 report and the early verdicts in our reviews round-up.
Image: Rockstar GamesFake reviews removed before launch
The trouble began before anyone could play. Video Games Chronicle reported on 17 November 2026 that fake user reviews had appeared on Metacritic days before release, and some were negative, pulling the user score down with no one having played the game. Metacritic removed the fake reviews and blocked further user reviews for GTA 6.
Metacritic normally holds user reviews back until a game has been out for at least 36 hours, a rule meant to stop review bombing by people who have not played. VGC cited a post on the r/GTA6 forum in which a user said trolls were already trying to review bomb the game. The article gives no count of removed reviews and no Metacritic statement.
What low-scoring players say
Gameplay and story
VGTimes sorted the written complaints into groups. Some players say GTA 6 feels closer to Red Dead Redemption 2 than to earlier GTA games. Others criticise the morality system, the story and the lead characters, the empty feel of parts of the map and slow missions. Some name the 30 fps console performance and bugs.
Price, size and format
Other reviews focus on the install size of more than 200 GB, the $80 price and boxed copies that hold a download code instead of a disc. One player gave a zero because there is no PC version yet, and a few reviews raise non-gameplay complaints that we do not assess here.
Image: Rockstar GamesHow to read a user score
VGTimes itself notes that many low ratings look like review bombing, for example one-line zeros and ones, and a zero given because the game was not a perfect score. It also lists complaints that look genuine. The honest reading is that both exist in the same pile of votes, and a headline average cannot separate them. Check the written reviews, critic reviews and your own tastes before drawing a conclusion.
What is not confirmed
Metacritic has not published how many reviews it removed or how it spots fake ones. No source has proven a coordinated campaign, and VGTimes only says that many scores resemble review bombing. The 4.9 figure and the 6,800 count are a snapshot from 21 November 2026 and will change. The 99 critic score is for the PS5 version, and we have not seen an Xbox Series X|S score yet.
Related guides
Sources
Reported: two outlets, numbers change by the hour
Who said it: Video Games Chronicle (17 Nov 2026) and VGTimes (21 Nov 2026), citing Metacritic pages. Sources: Video Games Chronicle and VGTimes (2 sources). Our view: The removal of fake reviews and the 4.9 score are reported by one outlet each, and they describe different moments. We have no Metacritic statement, so treat the numbers as a snapshot. Checked: 21 Nov 2026.
Frequently asked questions
What is the GTA 6 Metacritic user score?
VGTimes reported 4.9 out of 10 on 21 November 2026, from about 6,800 ratings. The score changes as more people vote.
What is the critic score?
99 out of 100 for the PS5 version, from 152 critic reviews according to VGTimes.
Did Metacritic remove GTA 6 reviews?
Yes. Video Games Chronicle reported that Metacritic removed fake user reviews posted before launch and blocked new ones for a time.
Is the user score review bombing?
Some ratings look like it, according to VGTimes, but no source has proven a coordinated campaign. Other ratings give genuine complaints.
Keep reading
Latest news

News
GTA 6 Chapter 1 Missables: What to Do Before Tourist Trap
Made by fans, for every GTA 6 player. Unofficial guide, not affiliated with Rockstar Games or Take-Two.Unofficial guide. GTA6Geek TrailersGuidesDatabaseMapCharactersYour countryPriceNews Language…
By Mia Carter · Published November 20, 2026

News
GTA 6 Dancers Cards: Locations Found So Far (Push Square)
Made by fans, for every GTA 6 player. Unofficial guide, not affiliated with Rockstar Games or Take-Two.Unofficial guide. GTA6Geek TrailersGuidesDatabaseMapCharactersYour countryPriceNews Language…
By Mia Carter · Published November 20, 2026

News
GTA 6 Unique Races: 40 Races, Six Groups, 30 Wins for 100%
Made by fans, for every GTA 6 player. Unofficial guide, not affiliated with Rockstar Games or Take-Two.Unofficial guide. GTA6Geek TrailersGuidesDatabaseMapCharactersYour countryPriceNews Language…
By Mia Carter · Published November 20, 2026

Leonida
GTA 6 Basketball Hoops: 100 in Leonida, 90 Needed for 100%
Made by fans, for every GTA 6 player. Unofficial guide, not affiliated with Rockstar Games or Take-Two.Unofficial guide. GTA6Geek TrailersGuidesDatabaseMapCharactersYour countryPriceNews Language…
By Mia Carter · Published November 20, 2026
🔔 Get GTA 6 news by email
We email you when we publish new GTA 6 news. No spam, unsubscribe any time.
NewsGTA 6 reviews round-up
NewsDay-one sales: 32.5 million copies
News1.84 billion release-day report
GuideCan you play GTA 6 offline
GuidePhoto mode and phone camera
Image: Rockstar Games